BUY, SELL, & TRADE!

Welcome to Collectors Cavern!
Collectors Cavern is our way of sharing something we've loved for years—collecting cards, toys, and figurines. Most of the items you’ll find here are from our collection or directly from official Canadian distributors, built piece by piece with the same excitement you probably feel when you add something special to yours. We started this because we know how tough it can be to find cards or other hot items these days. Between scalpers and crazy prices, it feels like the hobby has gotten harder for so many of us. That’s why we've decided to do things differently. Here, you’ll find fair prices and a safe way to buy — just one collector helping another. Whether you’re new to the hobby or a lifelong fan, we hope Collectors Cavern helps you find items that make you smile. Thanks for stopping by, and happy collecting!

- The Collectors Cavern Team

Pokémon - Sealed Product

We are currently experiencing an elevated demand for sealed Pokemon products. We are working as fast as possible to restock products. Thanks for your patience!

Pokémon - Singles

Missing cards to complete your master set? Ask us if we have a specific card in the Pokémon TCG expansions below.

Pokémon - Graded Slabs

Magic: The Gathering

MTG - Singles/Bulk

Missing cards to complete your master set? Ask us if we have a specific card in the MTG expansions below.

Toys & Collectibles

Video Games

Sports - Singles (Ask us for specific players)

Other Trading Card Games

TCG Accessories

FAQWhat payment options do you take?
For meetup sales and at events, we take cash, Interac E-Transfers, and PayPal (Friends & Family).What is your refund policy?
Due to the nature of TCG products, everything sold from Collectors Cavern is final sale.Are your products authentic?
Yes. We get our product from official Canadian distributors, which are authorized by the respective trading card game.Are you going to be at any events?
You'll sometimes catch us at expos, trade/card shows, and fairs. We'll announce if we are at one of these events.

BuylistTerms & Conditions for selling bulk
• We reserve the right to refuse bulk sales for any reason. Ex: Overstock, card conditions, fakes.
• We are only buying near mint cards/bulk in person as of now.
• Reserve at least 30 minutes of your time for us to go through your cards during our meetup sale.
• Sort your cards by set and card number. All submitted bulk are expected to be accurate and sorted, and subject to physical inspection.
• Submissions need to be accompanied with acceptable storage.
• We do not have a minimum buyout amount but will try to aim for at least $1.00 CAD.
• Payouts will be done via cash. We may payout via Interac E-Transfer for large amounts.

Pokémon Bulk
Energy Cards: $0.00 CAD
Common & Uncommon: $0.01 CAD
Rare: $0.05 CAD
Holos / Reverse Holos: $0.10 CAD
V / VMAX / VSTAR / GX / EX / TAG: $0.50 CAD
Full ETB Sleeves: $1.00 CAD

Terms & Conditions for selling raw cards & slabs
• We reserve the right to refuse sales for any reason. Ex: Overstock, card conditions, fakes.
• We are only buying near mint cards in person as of now. We may lean towards a preference of PSA graded slabs with a grade of 9 or higher.
• Reserve at least 30 minutes of your time for us to go through your cards during our meetup sale.
• Raw card submissions need to be in a penny sleeve and in a toploader or semi-rigid card saver.

Pokémon Raw Cards & Slabs
Cash: 60% of the current market price.
Trade: 70% of the current market price.

CONTACTLocal Pickup @ 1400 Major Mackenzie Drive East, L4S 0A1, Richmond HillText us @ 647-491-2500Email us @ [email protected]


Find us on Kijiji, FB Marketplace, or at a local event! (Celebrating 3 years of vending)